This is the old site. Please use the new site.

  Welcome, Guest. Please Login
Omega Owners Forum
 
  Home Shop Help Search Members Login  
 

This is the old site. Please use the new site.

www.omegaowners.com/forum/index.php.

 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why? (Read 1872 times)
Lincs Robert
Omega Knight
*****
Offline


Garage fits Omega

Posts: 1918
Lincolnshire
Gender: male

Drives: '99 Auto 3.0 Elite Saloon
Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
08. May 2011 at 22:27
 
Ok, so we know that the belt/tensioner life is 40,000 miles or 4 years - whichever comes first.

I can understand why the mileage limit as that roughly equates to an amount of wear.

So, why is there a time limit as well? What is there in the belt/tensioners that is time critical and could decay to the point of causing a major failure? The 2 cambelts that I changed seemed to be in perfect condition and the tensioners/rollers felt as good as the brand new ones.

I'm thinking about cars that do low miles, why a 4 year limit and not 5 or 6?

I'm not condoning pushing ones luck - just curious as to what actually fails and why.

Thanks - Rob
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Kevin Wood
Global Moderator
Admin Team
*******
Offline



Posts: 20377
Alton, Hampshire
Gender: male

Drives: 3.2 MV6 (LPG), Westfield
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #1 - 08. May 2011 at 22:31
 
The rubber belt can deteriorate with age and the tensioner bearings can dry out whether used or not. Thumbs Up!

The bearings normally feel fine when changed. The problem is, when they start to deteriorate, they go very quickly indeed.
Back to top
 

Tech2 services currently available. See TheBoy's price list: http://theboy.omegaowners.com/
 
IP Logged
 
TheBoy
Administrator
****************
Offline


TBE has an MOT!

Posts: 64817
Brackley, Northants
Gender: male

Drives: 98 MV6, 03 Elite, 00 25, 89 ZX10
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #2 - 08. May 2011 at 22:32
 
From a manufacturer's point of view, a time limit has to be on the warranty anyway. Thats why everything has a time limit, as well as mileage.

In case of this, does the belt age? Grease in the bearings? Tensioner ages?
Back to top
 

If you are going to kick a car, remember to wear appropriate footwear
Any posts are the result of my own views as a member of OOF, which may or may not be the same as my views as part of the Admin Team.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Lazydocker
Omega King
********
Offline


Victim of Pinky's Power
Trip!

Posts: 11336
Woodbridge, Suffolk
Gender: male

Drives: 2003 3.2 Elite Estate LPG Converted, inspected and Certified
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #3 - 08. May 2011 at 22:34
 
Kevin Wood wrote on 08. May 2011 at 22:31:
The rubber belt can deteriorate with age and the tensioner bearings can dry out whether used or not. Thumbs Up!

The bearings normally feel fine when changed. The problem is, when they start to deteriorate, they go very quickly indeed.


Hardly surprising when you consider how fast they're spinning Wink Wink
Back to top
 

Whatever it is... I didn't do it
Lazydocker  
IP Logged
 
Andy B
Over Active Poster
*********
Offline



Posts: 21988
Bury Lancs
Gender: male

Drives: 1999 3.0 Elite auto/TDM
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #4 - 08. May 2011 at 22:35
 
Vauxhall are just covering their backsides. It used to be 8 yrs/80 000 miles but had some tensioner failures so bottled it & halved the time/distance they should be changed.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
TheBoy
Administrator
****************
Offline


TBE has an MOT!

Posts: 64817
Brackley, Northants
Gender: male

Drives: 98 MV6, 03 Elite, 00 25, 89 ZX10
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #5 - 08. May 2011 at 22:38
 
Andy B wrote on 08. May 2011 at 22:35:
Vauxhall are just covering their backsides. It used to be 8 yrs/80 000 miles but had some tensioner failures so bottled it & halved the time/distance they should be changed.

And increased it back to please fleet managers, suffered an unacceptable failure rate, and lowered it again.

So its a little more than arse covering, they've done it twice, and got bitten twice.  Its clear that if you ignore the 40k/4yr, the risks, as deemed by GM (who desperately want it to be 80k/8yr), are too high
Back to top
 

If you are going to kick a car, remember to wear appropriate footwear
Any posts are the result of my own views as a member of OOF, which may or may not be the same as my views as part of the Admin Team.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Lazydocker
Omega King
********
Offline


Victim of Pinky's Power
Trip!

Posts: 11336
Woodbridge, Suffolk
Gender: male

Drives: 2003 3.2 Elite Estate LPG Converted, inspected and Certified
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #6 - 08. May 2011 at 22:38
 
Andy B wrote on 08. May 2011 at 22:35:
Vauxhall are just covering their backsides. It used to be 8 yrs/80 000 miles but had some tensioner failures so bottled it & halved the time/distance they should be changed.


Or realised that the revised interval was too long because of failures Roll Eyes Roll Eyes

You fancy trying your luck going 8 yrs/80k?
Back to top
 

Whatever it is... I didn't do it
Lazydocker  
IP Logged
 
Lincs Robert
Omega Knight
*****
Offline


Garage fits Omega

Posts: 1918
Lincolnshire
Gender: male

Drives: '99 Auto 3.0 Elite Saloon
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #7 - 08. May 2011 at 22:40
 
Fair enough - that all seems very sensible. Thankyou.

It's interesting that Vx started off with 80,000 miles and then dropped down to 40,000  - so it looked as if something in the grand plan of the design wasn't up to scratch. Any idea what it was?

IIRC there was talk of nylon pulleys desintegrating at the time - but our V6s dont have any do they?

Pal of mine runs a small garage, he recently showed me a Pug 306 engine whose cambelt was only a 1/4 inch wide! One very lucky owner.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Kevin Wood
Global Moderator
Admin Team
*******
Offline



Posts: 20377
Alton, Hampshire
Gender: male

Drives: 3.2 MV6 (LPG), Westfield
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #8 - 08. May 2011 at 23:12
 
IIRC Vauxhall tried the plastic tensioner route with the earlier C series engines and got burnt there too yet the Ford Zetec has them and the belt on those is pretty reliable at 100k/7 years, IIRC.

The bottom line is that different engines put these bearings through different levels of punishment as they run at different speeds, tensions and different levels of vibration being transmitted to them through both the mounting to the engine and the running of the belt.

As said, Vauxhall would have dearly loved to halve the frequency of this expensive maintenance task, and they tried twice, so the 40k/4 years rule has been tested well in real life and found to be appropriate. Wink
Back to top
 

Tech2 services currently available. See TheBoy's price list: http://theboy.omegaowners.com/
 
IP Logged
 
peteelite
Newbie
*
Offline



Posts: 18

Drives: v6elite
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #9 - 10. May 2011 at 09:25
 
Lincs Robert

I understand the point of your post is not to try to take your cam belt change to 80K/4yrs,just questioning the thinking behind it,asking questions is a good thing (otherwise forums like this would not exist). but have a look at my post 1st March "24 bent valves"..this happened while my new cam belt kit was sitting on my workbench "waiting for the right moment to be fitted"..well that moment came and went.

Regards.  Tongue
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Marks DTM Calib
Administrator
****************
Offline


Ex Member

Posts: 25671
Northern Hemisphere
Gender: male

Drives: Astra J, Mum Bus, Dexta Tractor, 108 DMU wip
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #10 - 10. May 2011 at 09:31
 
The V6 never had plastic idlers.

The 4 pot Ecotec does, the early ones suffered failures due to the use of to much glass in the glass loaded nylon so they were brittle.

You will note that they are still plastic but the 'mix' has been changed.
Back to top
 
Marks DTM Calib  
IP Logged
 
Elite Pete
Omega King
********
Offline


My spider senses are tingling

Posts: 17813
Northwich/Chester
Gender: male

Drives: Facelift Wheezel,Breaking 2001 MV6
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #11 - 10. May 2011 at 11:15
 
The owner of this one had a receipt for a cambelt change, look like the belt was the only thing they replaced.

...
Back to top
 

V6 Cambelts, tensioners and water pump replaced £235 including parts or supply your own £100 fitted
.
WWW http://www.facebook.com/home.php  
IP Logged
 
Abiton
Omega Knight
*****
Offline



Posts: 1064
Under Bonnet, nr Abingdon
Gender: male

Drives: Mk2 Golf, but the missus has a '96 2.0 'Select' woohoo!
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #12 - 10. May 2011 at 11:43
 
"Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?"

Because they are/were a bit crap underengineered.
Back to top
 

People are just about as happy as they have a mind to be.
Abraham Lincoln
 
IP Logged
 
Varche
Omega Baron
******
Offline



Posts: 3860
Andalucia, Spain
Gender: male

Drives: 97 pre mini facelift 3 litre auto RHD Elite saloon  and a 2000 Ford Ka !
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #13 - 10. May 2011 at 12:15
 
Abiton wrote on 10. May 2011 at 11:43:
"Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?"

Because they are/were a bit crap underengineered.



Can't argue with that. I think in this day and age the cam turning mechanism should last the life of the car. Very poor engineering I am afraid.

We had company Vectras a few years back. I asked a guy to go to a meeting in Cardiff in my place. His car was due 80,000 mile service that day. The cambelt gave up at 80,040 miles. Cost just over £1500 to fix.
Back to top
 

Finished breaking the red mfl Elite saloon in Spain. Got a shed load of stuff. Will post parts.
 
IP Logged
 
chrisgixer
Omega King
********
Offline


Black ones are faster.

Posts: 14570
Wokingham
Gender: male

Drives: "Omega Black" 3.2 Elite. Thanks to Joshwyatt.
Re: Cam belt/tensioner life of 4 years. Why?
Reply #14 - 10. May 2011 at 12:32
 
I always assumed the grease in the bearings dried out after a certain time, usually there is grease evident escaping from the seals, and the bearings themselves only lasted so many revolutions....?

But until we can examine a failure who knows.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print

This is the old site. Please use the new site.